Most college planning advice tells you what to do. This checklist is about what to ask.
These are the 15 questions students most often do not think about until it is too late to do anything about them. If you can answer these — or know where to find the answers — you are ahead of most applicants. Not because you are smarter, but because you asked the right questions at the right time.
Save this page. Come back to it. Use it as a starting point for conversations with your counselor, your parents, or Scout.
How to Use This Checklist
You do not need to answer all 15 questions today. Start with the section that matches where you are in the process:
- Freshman or sophomore? Skim the whole list so you know what is coming. Focus on the fit section.
- Junior? Start with testing and applications. These are the decisions you will make this year.
- Senior? Go straight to applications and money. These are the decisions in front of you right now.
Testing
1. Should I take the SAT, the ACT, or both?
They reward different strengths. Take a practice version of each to see which one fits you better. Do not just default to whichever one your school offers first.
Why it matters: Some students score significantly higher on one test. Choosing the right one can open doors.
2. Does this school superscore?
Superscoring means a college takes your best section scores across multiple test dates. Most schools superscore the SAT; fewer superscore the ACT. Policies vary, and some colleges still require or consider all scores.
Why it matters: It can change your retesting strategy. If a school superscores, retesting can only improve the score they review.
3. If a school is test optional, do my scores still matter?
"Test optional" means you are not required to submit scores, but strong scores can still help. If your scores are below a school's middle 50 percent, you may be better off not submitting.
Why it matters: This is a strategic decision, not a simple yes-or-no. The right choice depends on each school.
4. How many times should I take the test?
Two to three times is the sweet spot for most students. Beyond that, scores tend to plateau.
Why it matters: Your time is limited. At some point, essays and activities matter more than another 10 points.
Applications
5. What is the difference between Early Decision and Early Action?
Early Decision is binding — if you are accepted, you must attend. Early Action is not binding — you find out early but still have until May to decide. Some schools also offer Restrictive Early Action.
Why it matters: Choosing the wrong one can limit your options or lock you into a commitment you are not ready for.
6. Does this school track demonstrated interest?
Some colleges track visits, email engagement, information sessions, and contact with admissions. Others do not consider it at all. Check the school's Common Data Set under "level of applicant's interest."
Why it matters: If a school values demonstrated interest and you have never engaged with them, it can work against you.
7. Does this school admit by major, college, or program?
Some schools admit you to the university as a whole. Others admit you to a specific college or program — like engineering, nursing, or business — with different standards for each.
Why it matters: You could be a strong applicant overall but get denied from a competitive program. Know how each school handles this.
8. How many schools should I apply to?
Most counselors recommend 8 to 12 — a mix of likely, target, and reach schools. Applying to 20 does not make you safer. It makes you exhausted.
Why it matters: A balanced, well-researched list of 10 schools beats a scattered list of 20.
Money
9. What is the difference between sticker price and net price?
Sticker price is the published cost. Net price is what you actually pay after aid. A $75,000 school might cost you $25,000. A $30,000 school might offer less aid and cost more.
Why it matters: Never eliminate a school based on sticker price alone. Always check the net price calculator.
10. Does this school give merit aid, need-based aid, or both?
Need-based aid depends on your family's finances. Merit aid is based on grades, scores, talent, or leadership. Some schools are generous with merit; others give little or none.
Why it matters: Knowing the difference helps you build a list that is financially realistic — and avoid surprises when award letters arrive.
11. When does the FAFSA open, and when should I file?
The FAFSA traditionally opens around October 1 for the following school year, but the exact date can vary. Check StudentAid.gov and your state and college deadlines. Many aid programs are first-come, first-served.
Why it matters: Filing late can cost you money. Some aid runs out before the deadline.
12. Can I appeal my financial aid offer?
Yes. If you received a stronger offer from a comparable school or your family's situation has changed, you can ask the financial aid office to review your package.
Why it matters: Many schools will adjust — especially if they want you to enroll. But you have to ask.
Fit
13. What does "fit" actually mean beyond rankings?
Think about size, location, culture, academic structure, and support services. A school ranked #20 might be wrong for you. A school ranked #80 might be perfect.
Why it matters: You are choosing where to live and learn for four years. Rankings do not tell you if you will be happy there.
14. Should I visit before I apply?
If you can, yes. A visit tells you things a website cannot. If you cannot visit in person, virtual tours and student-created content on YouTube or Reddit can give you a more honest picture.
Why it matters: Some schools feel completely different in person than they do online — in both directions.
15. What if I do not know what I want to study?
"Undecided" is a valid answer. Look for schools with strong general education programs, easy major-switching policies, and a wide range of options.
Why it matters: Many students change their major. Choosing a school that handles that well gives you flexibility.
What to Do Next
You do not need to answer all 15 questions right now. Start with the ones that are most relevant to where you are in the process, and work through the rest as you go.
If you want help answering any of these, Scout can walk you through them based on your actual profile — your GPA, test scores, activities, and college list. Instead of generic answers, you get guidance that fits your situation.
CollegeHound is not a final-draft tool. It is a first-draft tool — a place to figure out what you do not know yet and start making sense of the process.
Get your free Launch Pass and start asking the questions that matter.